Hit the Ground Running

By Kathryn Craft  |  November 14, 2024  | 

photo adapted / Horia Varlan

In the masterful first paragraph of her debut novel, River Sing Me Home, British novelist Eleanor Shearer shows that you don’t need a cascade of words to set multiple levels of story movement in play.

It’s always fun to see what you can glean from an opening while approaching a novel stone cold, so let’s give it a go.

It was the blackest part of the night and Rachel was running. Branches tore at her skin. Birds, screeching, took flight at the pounding of her strides. The ground was muddy and uneven, slick with the residue of recent rains, and she slipped, falling hard against the rough bark of a palm tree. She slid down to the soil, to where ants marched and beetles scurried and unseen worms burrowed through the earth. With ragged breaths she gulped the heavy, humid air into her lungs. She could taste its dampness on her tongue, tinged with the acidic bite of her own fear. What had she done?

Line by line, let’s look at what Shearer accomplishes in only these 106 words. At the end of each explanation I’ll identify in blue the factors contributing to story movement.

 

  • It was the blackest part of the night and Rachel was running.

This story literally hits the ground running by setting the protagonist in motion—at night. A question is immediately raised: “Why?”

Character movement, anticipatory atmosphere, question raised

 

  • Branches tore at her skin.

This short, declarative sentence leaves no room for doubt—at the moment, Rachel cannot think of her comfort. Nature itself conspires to hold her back. We are entering a story in which stakes are attached. The question evolves: “Why is Rachel doing this dangerous thing?”

Obstacle, interactive setting, stakes, prose support, story question extended

 

  • Birds, screeching, took flight at the pounding of her strides.

Rachel blasts through obstacles with pounding strides, exposing her desire and proving her agency. Shearer’s verb choices—“screeching” and “pounding”—extend the sense of danger. Commas spotlight the reaction from the birds.

Desire, agency, specific verb usage, an interactive setting, prose support

 

  • Even the birds take flight, as if picking up on Rachel’s fear.

Whatever is going on with Rachel will have an impact on her world.

Interactive setting, foreshadowing, spreading stakes, anticipation of an off-screen antagonist, fear

 

  • The ground was muddy and uneven, slick with the residue of recent rains, and she slipped, falling hard against the rough bark of a palm tree.

Nature continues to pose obstacles, this time causing her to fall. The palm tree, and the humid air to come, place the story in a tropical locale. As she suffers this mishap, the forward pace of the prose is slowed with longer sentences, and multiple commas, as if the reader herself was mired in mud.

Obstacles suggest a gauntlet, interactive setting, conflict, setting orientation, consequences, prose support

 

  • She slid down to the soil, to where ants marched and beetles scurried and unseen worms burrowed through the earth.

Rachel’s flight intersects with a universe in which living beings come and go, appear and hide, and go about their work as they see fit. This sentence carries enough subtext to further refine the story question: Is Rachel free to move about as she sees fit, and if not, what hidden forces are impeding her?

Subtext, interactive setting, question raised

 

  • “With ragged breaths she gulped the heavy, humid air into her lungs.”

Her ragged breaths raise questions: Has she been running a long time? Is she being chased? Is she unused to running? Is she ill? The “heavy, humid air” suggests a theme of freedom: here, it’s hard to even breathe freely.

Question raised, interactive setting, clue to possible theme, subtext

 

  • “She could taste its dampness on her tongue, tinged with the acidic bite of her own fear.”

Another sense, taste, is brought into play, helping us bond with Rachel’s experience and emotional state, and inviting us to think about how dampness might “taste.”

Sense imagery, unbalancing reader, visceral emotion

 

  • “What had she done?”

The final question in this opening paragraph bonds Rachel with those of us who have also doubted our decisions once the going got tough.

Raised question, anticipation for story to come

 

 Now, let’s look at what isn’t here. There’s no character description, and yet we can see Rachel in our mind’s eye. There’s no block of setting description, just interactions. There’s no backstory to tell us who Rachel is or what caused this nighttime flight—just questions that pull us forward.

Let’s see if you got the gist of the story. Here’s the description:

Her search begins with an ending.…

The master of the Providence plantation in Barbados gathers his slaves and announces the king has decreed an end to slavery. As of the following day, the Emancipation Act of 1834 will come into effect. The cries of joy fall silent when he announces that they are no longer his slaves; they are now his apprentices. No one can leave. They must work for him for another six years. Freedom is just another name for the life they have always lived. So Rachel runs.

Away from Providence, she begins a desperate search to find her children—the five who survived birth and were sold. Are any of them still alive? Rachel has to know. The grueling, dangerous journey takes her from Barbados then, by river, deep into the forest of British Guiana and finally across the sea to Trinidad. She is driven on by the certainty that a mother cannot be truly free without knowing what has become of her children, even if the answer is more than she can bear. These are the stories of Mary Grace, Micah, Thomas Augustus, Cherry Jane and Mercy. But above all this is the story of Rachel and the extraordinary lengths to which a mother will go to find her children…and her freedom.

Now you know why she was running, but that knowledge neither adds to nor detracts from the power of this opening paragraph, in which every single sentence contributes to story movement.

Obviously, this is not first draft writing. Each of these sentence shines through too many facets. But imagine, if when starting a new project, you held yourself to the inclusion of just one aspect of story movement in each sentence; that would still be an incredible gift to self. Movement begets movement. What movement you create in your opening will continue to move within you, making the drafting easier.

I don’t know anything about Eleanor Shearer’s process, but I can tell that this opening is not the product of the question, “What do I need to tell my readers on page one?” In a YouTube interview as part of the Sankofa Pan African series, Shearer explained that it was while she was exploring the topic of slavery in the Caribbean for her master’s degree that she realized the limitations of research. “Parts of the past that I’m interested in are at risk of being forgotten or little understood,” she said. With so few people from that time leaving behind written accounts, she added, “you’re forced to imagine yourself into those gaps.” Her desire to write the novel was personal—her grandparents were from the Caribbean—and she wanted to tell Rachel’s personal story. The roll call of her children’s names evokes that beautifully. Her website adds this at the end of the book description:

Only once she knows their stories can she rest.

Only then can she finally find home.

This added context confirms my suspicion that the question Shearer asked herself was not what readers should know, but this: “If I were Rachel, what must I be doing at the start of this story?” With that, Rachel figuratively and literally hit the ground running, and invited us readers to come along for the ride. For all the invitations extended to us in blue, above, we’ll hop on board, trusting that we’ll eventually learn why Rachel is running. For now, we just need to sense the tension surrounding her flight.

The “running” in your novel may not be literal. Your character could be painting a house a shocking color of pink. But if you give us a taste of her desire, hint at the obstacles in her way, and foreshadow the stakes she’s trying to avoid, we’ll sense she has a good reason for doing so. Then, you can’t go wrong by enhancing that story movement with any of the other techniques Shearer displays.

Tell us: how do you set your protagonist in motion (or how will you revise to do so)? How do you invite the reader to participate in your story (or how will you revise to do so)? How do you keep story movement  revved up within you (how can you revise so that your character’s desire, goal-oriented action, and stakes can do so)? If you’ve read River Sing Me Home, what do you make of how this opening paragraph set up the novel?

[coffee]

18 Comments

  1. Kristin Hacken South on November 14, 2024 at 9:15 am

    Wow, Kathryn! I love this. Thank you for showing us — rather than telling us — some of the deeper levels of utility a sentence or paragraph can serve. I’m making a list against which to check my later drafts. As usual, Writer Unboxed comes through with identification and explanation of yet another facet of great writing. :)

    • Kathryn Craft on November 14, 2024 at 10:40 am

      I’m glad you found it useful, Kristin!

  2. Bart on November 14, 2024 at 9:21 am

    Excellent piece. Thanks!

  3. Donald Maass on November 14, 2024 at 12:08 pm

    Hey Kathryn, for me, there is something else missing from that opening: narrative voice.

    The passage is largely action, which is fine and not badly written, but with little to know about this character, nothing from inside until the last sentence, what is there to engage the reader emotionally? Danger-danger, run-run openings are pretty common, so the effect of this one, for me, is pretty low.

    Sounds like a great novel, though, I’ve no doubt it would worth a read, but I have to dissent a little and say this opening paragraph doesn’t quite light me up.

    • Kathryn Craft on November 14, 2024 at 12:59 pm

      Fair point, Don. Asking what would make this opening a more emotional experience is a great question, one I failed to ask by suggesting the “cold” reading even though I didn’t come to it cold. I sensed the emotional nature of the novel through the cover copy and the setup of a short prologue, which ends:

      “We tried to glide through this half-life, this life without history or future, but our endless present had ways of stretching itself out, lying across time, until our lives had movement and color again. At night, we whispered stories to the children of old gods in our homelands, in a tongue the white men couldn’t understand.

      Still the hurricanes came. Still the children were taken away and sold across the sea. But they were sold with a little seed inside them that sang to them of another life.

      Everything laid down shallow roots. But what couldn’t go deep went wide, tapping the oceans, tunneling to the islands nearby, where others were also trying and failing to live without memory of yesterday or thought of tomorrow.

      Without roots, things die, at the hands of the white men or in the heat of the midday sun. The soil ran rich with our blood, and the roots fed on our bodies. It made the roots strong. Shallow, but strong.

      There was hope for this new world, after all.”

      Which of course is fiction speak for “the s**t’s about to hit the fan, which I suspected was the reason behind the run. Sorry to short-change you.

  4. Vijaya Bodach on November 14, 2024 at 1:57 pm

    Kathryn, I do love a thorough sentence-by-sentence analysis and I appreciate Don’s point about the why–the flap gives enough. Forward motion. I took this as a lesson for my singing too–forward motion always, even on the long notes. Thank you.

    • Kathryn Craft on November 14, 2024 at 2:43 pm

      I love a crescendo on a long note, Vijaya—so dramatic! I too have learned many writing lessons from my son’s vocal training (free for Mom as she sits in the waiting area!). Thanks for reading.

  5. Valerie Ormond on November 14, 2024 at 4:40 pm

    Thank you for this, Kathryn, and I, too, appreciated the sentence-by-sentence breakdown explanation. Conciously thinking about story movement is a tool I need to sharpen in my writer’s toolbox.

    • Kathryn Craft on November 14, 2024 at 8:37 pm

      Good thinking, Valerie! As a former dancer, I can’t help thinking that way.

  6. Alicia Butcher Ehrhardt on November 14, 2024 at 5:43 pm

    Thanks for an intense writing exercise. I used it to evaluate the beginning of the first novel in my mainstream trilogy.

    To set my first main character in action, I put you in her head as she waits for her fate – with a sense of doom:

    New York City;
    February 25, 2005;
    11 P.M.

    I, KARENNA ELIZABETH Ashe, being of sound mind, do… But that’s it, isn’t it? Being here proves I am not of sound mind. She wished, for the nth time, she had not agreed to tonight’s interview. They have Laura Hillenbrand—isn’t that enough? But, “…we need more people like you”—meaning ‘damaged like you’—“to speak up…” The handwritten note from Night Talk’s host put the burden of duty on psyche and skeleton held together by spider’s silk. Dana didn’t know what she asked for. But I know. Winter dies tonight. Of exposure.

    “Kary? Are you okay?”

    “I’m fine. Why?” Kary felt like her own straitjacket, hugging herself tightly with goose-bumped arms.

    “You seemed alarmed.” Elise’s face was a study in tact. “Then you went further into that head of yours.”

    Dear Elise, worrying about her difficult hermit author. Kind Elise, who hadn’t demanded tiresome explanations: Why not a suburban book signing? Why national television? And why now?

    Ehrhardt, Alicia Butcher. PRIDE’S CHILDREN: PURGATORY (Book 1 of the Trilogy) . Trilka Press. Kindle Edition.

    The reader has had a tiny prologue about a crazy secret marriage to invite the reader to ‘participate in the story’. They are plunged into the panicked thinking of Kary who was persuaded to sit for a live TV interview out of obligation. The person with her in the greenroom is her agent, who is also in the dark about her motives. The wait keeps the ‘story movement revved up.’

    Hope the formatting holds.

    I didn’t realize, until you asked, how many of your questions I had answered – because the beginning didn’t feel complete until I had.

    It even has (with the prologue) a mention of the three main characters, two key secondary ones, and the core of the novel.

    • Kathryn Craft on November 14, 2024 at 8:42 pm

      Thanks for sharing this excerpt, Alicia! Too often writers will put us in the head of a character who is mulling over their past. Fear for the immediate future is another thing altogether. I can definitely sense the tension. Well done!

  7. Carol Baldwin on November 14, 2024 at 8:21 pm

    What an amazing opening and a great analysis. Off to put this book on my ever growing TBR pile. Thank you!

  8. Kathryn Craft on November 14, 2024 at 8:43 pm

    Thanks Carol, enjoy!

  9. Bob Cohn on November 18, 2024 at 1:09 pm

    Great post, Kathryn. Thank you. You are probably familiar with The First 100 Words by Stephen Parrish and his staff. He’s editor of the Lascaux Review, and it was probably written to guide those who submit to their publication. Excepting this post of course, it’s the most powerful and helpful sixty-seven pages of material on writing I’ve come across.
    He addresses eight topics, the first one of which is Give Us Something To Care About. It may have been written for writers of articles, but I think it applies to novels as well. That first topic, of course, was the chord your post struck with me. I go back over it every month or so just to make sure I haven’t let one of those valuable eight items slip.

    • Kathryn Craft on November 19, 2024 at 6:02 pm

      Actually, Bob, I don’t know that one but will check it out. Thanks for the recommendation, it sounds great!

  10. Barbara Morrison on November 26, 2024 at 9:51 am

    Brilliant analysis, Kathryn! Maybe you could follow up with a similar analysis of a less action-orieted opening?

Leave a Reply Cancel Reply





This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.