The Collage Method

By Barbara O'Neal  |  November 27, 2019  | 

At the Uncon, I guided a session on right brain plotting, which was partly about music, but mostly about collage.  A few people have asked about the method since then, and as this is my last post for a bit, I thought this would be a good thing to leave you with.  I collage everything, and sometimes pretty elaborately.  The collage for Lady Luck’s Map of Vegas was a hat box lit with tiny purple neon lights and came complete with a toy Thunderbird car. (I actually tossed this in a move and have regretted it ever since.)

One of the things quite a few people said was, “If I’d know it was a collage workshop, I wouldn’t have wanted to come, but then I had this insight/experience/recognition.”  It’s a great method to let you get out of your head and let the book talk TO you.

Another thing I did for the workshop was play 30 seconds to a minute of a song, then moved to another, through a playlist that was pretty random.  You can do the same thing with Spotify or Pandora or even your own bank of songs. Set the program to randomize through a big variety of songs and listen for a minute, then push on to the next.  (The playlist I used for this session is here.  Thanks to Angela D’Ambrosio for putting it up.)

Without further explanation, the method:

I can’t remember exactly who taught me the fine, messy art of collaging a novel—it was either Jenny Crusie or Susan Wiggs. Pretty sure Susan mentioned it first, but either way, it’s been a part of my process for a long time.  Some writers scoff at this process, finding it a waste of time. Maybe some of you fail to see how an art-based project can help you build a book that’s made of words. If you’ve never tried it, however, maybe give it a shot.

The basic process is straight-forward: you use images and other physical or visual materials to create a snapshot of your book. It can be very simple or very complex, and does not require any particular skills or any kind of artistic bent. Jenny, the former art teacher, builds astonishing collages, three dimensional and with all sorts of gadgets and gizmos. Susan builds them of paper board and magazine cut-outs. I fall somewhere in-between.(This was for How to Bake a Perfect Life.)

The product is not the actual point of this exercise. It’s a process tool. Using tactile, visual, or textural materials, you get out of your logical, verbal, methodical left brain and allow the loose, associative right brain to play.

Let me stress again that you do not need artistic talent. You don’t need to create something “beautiful.” No one else has to see it. Ever. You don’t even have to keep what you make, though I find the snapshot very grounding over the weeks and months it takes to complete a book. For example: On the current board, a photo of a row of battered, paint splattered female cowboy books brings me back again and again to a basic concept of one main character.

Assemble your materials

Base
You will need a base. I tend to like the kind of foam board kids use for science fair projects. It can be any size you like, though do give yourself a little space for play, no less than 8×10. I have space on my office wall, plus I’m nearsighted and don’t wear my glasses at the computer, so mine tend to be pretty big, but it really does not matter.   It also doesn’t have to be a flat board—you might enjoy browsing around Michael’s or some other hobby store to look at the various options. I once created a gorgeous collage in a hat box, an elaborate thing complete with purple Christmas lights.

Magazines and paper
If you’re flush, by all means go to the local bookstore and buy a bunch of new magazines. I’m madly in love with a series of periodicals published by Stampington, especially Bella Grace and Artful Blogging, which give me the kind of images I need for my women’s fiction novels about women and cooking and all those things. I splurge on them regularly to have material, but it isn’t necessary. You can find lots of periodicals at library sales and thrift shops, and there is a magazine for almost anything you can imagine. Great general choices are photography and art magazines, travel magazines, and home decorating magazines like Veranda.

Other paper products you might enjoy are tissue paper and scrapbooking sheets—there are big blocks of them at hobby stores like Michael’s. Browsing for materials can be an exercise in brainstorming in itself. You’ll find yourself thinking about the general tone and feeling of your book—is it more a delicate green thing, or a sturdy leather?

Other supplies

Get some glue sticks. They don’t have to be fancy. Basic glue sticks from the grocery store will do. Scissors, of course, to cut out the photos and patterns and color swatches you need. In recent years, I’ve used Pinterest and my color printer pretty heavily because I can search for exactly the image I need, and print it out. A Chinese goddess, say, or an actor who represents a character.

You can also use other bits and pieces—I’ve used milagros and magnets, glitter, paint, leaves and branches. Anything goes. Once I built a collage from a kit for a shrine to a rock star and covered the outside with shredded red Santa Barbara incense. Bonus: it perfumed my office for months.

Timing
To build the collage, I need to be somewhere beyond the very beginning. To get a strong snapshot, I need a sense of the characters and where the book is going, and what my theme or main ideas are.  You can, however, collage at any point within the book. Whenever it feels right to you.

 

Process, step by step

  1. Start with a session of cutting out photos, images, even just pages of color that appeal, and stack them up. Maybe listen to music that suits the book, drink a cup of tea and let your mind wander. If you want images of your characters but modern magazines aren’t cutting it, try places like Deviant Art or run an image search for an actor who might work. You can also just capture the spirit of a character in an image—a hard-boiled guy staring at the camera, a leaping athlete.

Mainly at this stage, you’re just collecting whatever images and things that catch your eye. It doesn’t have to directly relate to your book—let the girls (or guys) in the basement lead you—those clouds! That red car! Maybe you’ll have gritty urban landscapes, or castles, or dogs, or feet. Don’t think much, just let your eye wander. You are not committed to keeping anything. Better to have more to build with than less.

It’s also not just about pictures or bits of color. If you see words that embody your theme, grab them. If other words give a ripple of recognition, cut those out, too.   I’ve sometimes made word images at Wordle to help me get a handle on complex ideas.

  1. Once you have your pile of materials, give yourself some time to play with arranging them. Don’t glue anything just yet, just loosely shuffle your pictures, rearrange, step back, try again. Play with relationships, words, strips of color. You might like slipping some scrapbooking paper behind photos, or looping things together with a little string.

Again, don’t glue anything here. Just let it be for a little while. When you discover an arrangement that feels good, take a break. Do something else, clear your head, and come back later. You’ll see more. Maybe something will feel wrong and you get rid of it. Maybe you need more color, or a different kind of image. Remember: this is not meant to be a work of art. It’s a process tool.

  1. Once you feel happy with the layout, you can start gluing things in place. Take your time. I do listen to music, sometimes drink a nice cup of tea, let myself fall into the mood.

Get the basic layout in place, and then step back. Is anything missing? Do you feel a need to get some paintbrushes and add some color, or maybe spritz it with some ink? Need more words to keep your theme in mind? Print them out, or use an app like Word Swag to put words over pictures and print those out.

  1. Finished!

You do not have to put the collage where you can see it, but it helps me to see it constantly. I prop it up in my office where it is the thing I see when I come into the room. First, this offers a focal point—my job, during these months, is to write this book. Second, I catch on new images every time, and that keeps my grounded in a holographic version of the book, right there in time and space.

If you don’t have wall space, maybe the back of a door or closet door. Or take a photo and upload it to the wallpaper on your laptop. If you don’t want to look at it, or are one of those people who likes an uncluttered environment, tuck it away. The main work is done.

One last note. I’m often asked if you can do this process in a digital format. You can, of course, but I strongly suggest trying the paper version first. Some parts of the brain are more fully accessed through tactile actions—the cutting, writing, glueing are all ways to reach those areas.

Any questions? I’m here to answer if I can. Have you ever used this method for your books? Are you one of the resistors who can’t see why in the world it would help? Let’s talk about it in the comments.

Posted in

11 Comments

  1. Beth Havey on November 27, 2019 at 11:37 am

    Thanks, Barbara. Your collage echoes what was once called a VISION BOARD. I made one for my third novel (unpublished) and I still have it. I searched for photos that either echoed the rooms and places in my novel or came very close. And I think this is true for most writers–with or without a visual image–at any given time I can walk the rooms of the house in that novel (FORGIVING) see the greenhouse, the gardens, the road in my imaginary city in Michigan. I can live there. Maybe someday readers will too.



  2. Denise Willson on November 27, 2019 at 11:56 am

    Thanks, Barbara! I was in bed nursing a migraine during this class, so I’m happy to see it here.

    Oh, and I am so very sad to know you won’t be posting for a while. While I know you need to focus on your writing, know you will be missed. Keep in touch, my friend.

    Hugs, Dee



  3. Bob Cohn on November 27, 2019 at 11:57 am

    Barbara,

    Thank you, I never thought of using this for a novel or writing, but I saw it used by directors as a start on or an anchor for the dramatic experience they wanted to produce for an audience, a kind of middle step or way to get from the script to the production. I didn’t have much luck with it, but I saw colleagues use it beautifully and in several different ways.

    While I think of myself as right-brained, I’m afraid the left side of my right brain is the stronger side. I find I envy those who can think this way, turn an image into a story. It seems to be a powerful tool.



  4. Lara Schiffbauer on November 27, 2019 at 12:03 pm

    I have made Pinterest boards for all three of my novels. I am a very visual person, and “seeing” my book helps me to transform the abstract in my head into the concrete structure of words. My current book is in our time and world and so I even picked out rooms where my protagonist lives and found it fascinating how her personality developed in my mind as I figured out what things she’d like to have around her. However, I like the physical process you describe here, and would like to try it to see how much more the handling of pictures and accessing words or singular objects would encourage inspiration and story development, not just setting or character development.



  5. Susan Setteducato on November 27, 2019 at 12:13 pm

    Barbara, as a visual artist, I’ve always sketched my characters and settings and used music to evoke a mood for my stories. I’ve also used Pinterest to gather images onto boards, but I really love the idea of having a collage in real time, right in the room with me. The way you describe the process – collecting, sorting, looking, stepping away, coming back – almost echoes the writing process, but uses the other more playful part of the brain. I’ve just started a second book and this may be just what I need. And I really would love to have seen that hat box!



  6. Janet Fox on November 27, 2019 at 12:28 pm

    I learned to collage years ago. It really appeals to me in that right-brained way. If I could upload a photo here I would.



  7. Barbara Linn Probst on November 27, 2019 at 1:07 pm

    Love this: “Using tactile, visual, or textural materials, you get out of your logical, verbal, methodical left brain and allow the loose, associative right brain to play.” And I find it’s so, so true that it just ain’t the same on the computer! We need to touch and sense in order for that other part of ourselves to appear. I think there’s also something about slowing down and taking the time … Not to disparage the left brain, but we need both. Thank you for showing us a way to include them!



  8. Deborah Makarios on November 27, 2019 at 7:10 pm

    I did something akin to this with my first novel. A chess board became the map of the land the characters travel through, with chess pieces and various other items spread across it to represent places, people, items, events.
    Bonus: I could move the pieces along with the story, thus seeing the ‘present’ at a glance.
    For other projects I have gathered images but seldom gone as far as actually assembling them into a fixed form.



  9. Peter Dann on November 27, 2019 at 7:35 pm

    I found this fascinating. Anthony Powell, English author of the acclaimed twelve volume “Dance to the Music of Time” novel sequence, used this method extensively, as his biographer Hilary Spurling makes clear in her biography “Anthony Powell”: “Collage seemed to clear his mind, offer new possibilities, sometimes even to throw up patterns that anticipate developments in the Dance”. Apparently it’s still possible to view Powell’s collages in the English country house where he created them.



  10. Leslie Budewitz on November 27, 2019 at 7:55 pm

    Isn’t it funny how you use or create a tool, and later forget about it? I made a bulletin board for my first series and created a sketchbook for the second, but now that I’m working on something new, I completely forgot about these tools. Since each book has its own process, I think collage will be a part of this one. Thank you for walking us through it!



  11. Sandi Ward on December 6, 2019 at 8:52 pm

    I love this…now I want to make a collage for my work-in-progress. I think it will help me focus on some of the telling details I’d like to incorporate, and inspire me to stay focused on the particular tone and mood I’m trying to achieve.